• AI Vibe Daily
  • Posts
  • Why ChatGPT Doesn’t Actually Restore Your Old Photos

Why ChatGPT Doesn’t Actually Restore Your Old Photos

What really happens when you ask ChatGPT to ‘fix’ a photo—and why it might give your grandpa a new face.

Author

Theo T
August 08, 2025

🧠 What Went Wrong?

A user on Reddit shared how they tried to use ChatGPT to enhance a rare photo of their grandfather, only to get back an image that looked more like Nelson Mandela. When they asked what they did wrong, the community was clear:

“It's not 'upscaling' anything, it's making its own new image.” “It generates something very similar, but not exactly the same.”

In short: ChatGPT didn’t touch the original image—it generated an entirely new version based on guesswork.

🔍 What’s Actually Happening Behind the Scenes

  • ChatGPT cannot “restore” or “repair” images like photo-editing software. Instead, it “imagines” a new image that resembles the prompt.

  • That means details get changed—sometimes subtly, like expressions or features—because ChatGPT doesn’t copy your photo, it reinterprets it.

  • If you want strict fidelity to the original (such as preserving expressions or background), ChatGPT’s current image generation tools can’t guarantee it.

🧑‍💼 Expert Take on AI-Driven “Restoration”

A TechRadar article recently investigated this trend—revealing that while creative prompts can produce gorgeous color versions of vintage photos, the process is more style-based recreation than restoration. According to the author:

“It's not actually restoring the image… you might think of it as a recreation by an art forager with a modernist streak.”
The model can imitate period-accurate details, but sometimes “hand positions, environments, and facial expressions were imagined or altered.”

So even if the result looks impressive, it may not reliably preserve the likeness or composition of the original photograph.

✅ Bottom Line: Using ChatGPT for Photo Enhancement

🎯 Want…

✅ Use Tool

⚠️ Expect

Accurate, side-by-side enhancement

❌ No

Face distortion or changed expression

Artistic reimagining or colorized recreation

✅ Yes

Accepts new artistic detail, but not fidelity

Restoration of background or unique pose

❌ No

May replace or redraw unrelated details

ChatGPT’s image tools are great for imaginative experimentation—but they’re not built for precise photo restoration. When you ask it to “enhance” or “colorize,” it generates a new version based on training data, not the actual image you provided.

💡 Tips for Better AI-Driven Enhancements

  1. Be explicit in your prompt: Use precise language like, “Preserve facial features exactly; don’t change expression or cropping.” This can marginally improve results.

  2. Overlay the AI version on top of the original image to visually inspect alignment—if parts shift, it’s a new image rather than a remastered one.

  3. Use dedicated image-editing tools if you need preservation of identity or composition—ChatGPT’s model isn't suited for forensic or archival work.

🧭 Big Picture: Why ChatGPT Does This

  • OpenAI’s safety rules prevent the model from generating exact likenesses of real people—avoiding misuse or deep‑fake-style forgery.

  • The underlying algorithm works by “understanding” the concept of an old photo and reimagining it—not by digitally repairing pixel-by-pixel detail.

  • As one Redditor put it: it “picked up on certain details,” but ended up generating an image like an actor hired to play someone, not the actual person.

🛠️ What You Can Try Instead

  • If your goal is colorization or increasing resolution visually, try tools like Midjourney, DALL·E, or automatic colorization models with clear “no reinterpretation” prompts.

  • For precision restoration, look into programs like Adobe Photoshop, Topaz Labs, or specialized photo-restoration software that perform true pixel-level enhancements.

  • Tools like Flux Kontext are preferred if you need to preserve background and composition while making specific edits—rather than full reimagining.

⚠️ Final Thought

If you asked ChatGPT to restore a photo and it ended up looking like someone else entirely—you’re not alone. Many users run into this because the model is reconstructing, not restoring, the photo. When preserving identity or composition matters, treat ChatGPT more like an illustrator, not a restoration tool.

Want more content like this? Subscribe to our daily AI newsletter at AIVibeDaily.com